2026 Medicare Star Ratings: Steady, but with notable shifts

The 2026 Medicare Star Ratings are out. Overall, it's not as bad as many expected. --- Despite fears of further decline, average 2026 Star Ratings (per Healthcare Dive) held steady at 3.98 (compared to 3.96 last year). Here's a summary of the shifting landscape among the largest players: -Kaiser had another year of excellent star performance, with nearly all its members in plans receiving 4+ stars. -UnitedHealthcare remains a market leader, with 77% of members in plans rated 4 stars or higher. Minor changes in performance compared to last year. -Humana saw a meaningful drop to only 20% of members in 4+ star plans, down from 25%. -Aetna also declined: 81% of members in 4+ star plans, down from 89%. -Elevance and Centene posted the biggest improvements. Elevance jumped from 40% to 53% in 4+ star plans, while Centene leapt from 1% to 18%. None of these were particularly surprising since most companies started sharing some results before they were released by CMS. --- Star Ratings directly influence plan bonus payments and rebates, which can total billions annually. Specifically, the 2026 Star Ratings impact 2027 payments. For plans below the 4-star threshold, the financial squeeze is immediate. For 2027, it’s reasonable to expect leaner benefits and/or premium hikes as these plans recalibrate. Some insurers are reducing service areas, narrowing networks, or pursuing contract diversification to maximize favorable ratings. Others like Clover Health, who took a major hit on their largest contract with 97% of their members dropping below 4-star, are publicly challenging CMS’s methodology. --- For plans (unlike the past few years in #PartD) it's no longer just about growth. They're more focused on profitability and #quality. What benefit design changes do you think we'll see in 2027?

  • graphical user interface, application, Teams
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore content categories