Cruxx reposted this
FDA clears Medtronic’s Hugo robot for urology a meaningful step, but nowhere near a shake-up...yet. Medtronic finally has U.S. clearance for Hugo RAS, covering prostatectomy, nephrectomy and cystectomy. It’s a real milestone and the first time that a major strategic has put a da Vinci-class system into the U.S. market. But the press release tells only half the story. What actually stands up to scrutiny? The pivotal IDE trial was prospective and multi-centre 137 patients across the procedures that matter in urology. It’s solid enough for a regulatory green light, not a soft launch or experimental deployment. Hospitals now have a credible alternative in a market that’s been dominated by one vendor for two decades. Where the enthusiasm needs tempering. This isn’t a comparative study. It’s single-arm. It shows safety and basic effectiveness not superiority. The clearance is urology only. No general surgery. No gyn. No hernia. Those are the real volume engines in soft-tissue robotics. Surgeon switching costs are enormous. A high-volume robotic urologist isn’t changing consoles and workflows on the back of an early dataset and a marketing message. What this actually changes It removes the “no U.S. clearance” cloud that’s hovered over Hugo since launch. It gives hospitals leverage in negotiations, especially as capital budgets tighten. It signals that the next 3–5 years will be a true multi-vendor environment something the market hasn’t genuinely seen before in the US. But let’s be clear: this doesn’t dent Intuitive’s position today. Not with a single-indication clearance, limited evidence, and no demonstrated economic advantage yet. This is the start of Medtronic entering the ring, not the start of Intuitive losing its grip. Anyone have anything else to weigh in?